Four Rak’ah equivalent to Lailatul Qadr!
Bismillahi wal Hamdulillah Was Salaatu Was Salaamu ‘Alaa Rasoolillah:
The prophet Sallallahu alaihi wa Salam said “Whoever prays Ishaa congregation and (then) prays four (rak’ah) before he leaves the masjid then it is equivalent to lailatul qadr”
(Collected by At Tabaraani in ‘Al Awsat’ 1/2/1)
Shaikh Al Albaani mentions the hadeeth in ‘Silsilatul Ahaadeeth ad Da’eefah and highlights the fact that this version of the hadeeth is weak due to the presence of Imaam Abu Haneefah in its chain.
He mentions (Da’eefah 11/102):
“..similarly the rest of its narrators are trustworthy except Abu Haneefah –Rahimahullah- for indeed the Imaams (of Hadeeth) have declared him weak (in hadeeth), just as the detailed clarification of this) has preceded under hadeeth 458, the like of which you will find in no other place.”
He then goes to mention:
“Although the hadeeth has occurred authentically attributed to a group from among the companions, without the mention of the wording:
“..before he leaves the masjid..”
He then goes on to mention the version attributed to Abdullah Ibn Amr collected by Ibn Abi Shaiba in his ‘Musanaf’ 1/72/2 with the wording:
“Whoever prays four rak’ah after Ishaa Prayer then they will be like their equivalent performed on Lailatul Qadr”
Shaikh Albaani then mentions: “Its chain of narration is authentic” then Ibn abi Shaiba narrates the same narration from Aaisha, Ibn Masood, Ka’b ibn Maati’, Mujaahid, Abdur Rahmaan ibnil Aswad and mentions chains of narration going back to them all being authentic with the exception of the narration of Ka’b then Shaikh Albaani mentions:
“even though these narrations are attributed to companions they carry the ruling of ‘Ar Raf’ (i.e attribution to the messenger) since the subject of the narrations is not the type of thing they may have said from their opinion, as Is apparent”
(Ad Da’eefah 11/103)
Note: The established version then, does not make it a condition that one must perform them before leaving the masjid to obtain the reward.
Imaamul Iraaqi has mentioned:
“This hadeeth is more profound in meaning than the hadeeth that was mentioned before since in it is the establishment of a person obtaining the virtue of Lailatul Qadr even if that is not on Lailatul Qadr, so what do you think about the one who does so on Lailatul Qadr itself!
(Tarhut tathreeb 5/150)
A sister posed a question to the Noble Ustaadh (hafidhahullaah) (on which I added as its so beneficial)
Salaama alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakaatu, BaarakAllah feekum for this beneficial post. I just wanted to make sure I haven’t misunderstood inshaAllah. The version attributed to Abdullah ibn ‘Amr doesn’t mention that the prayer is in congregation (unless I misread/misunderstood, Allahu ‘allam). So if a woman prays ‘isha at home and prays four raka’a afterwards, are those four rak’ah still equivalent to laylatul qadr?
ahspubs December 7, 2011 at 8:41 am Reply
That is correct since the condition of being in the masjid is not mentioned in that which is Saheeh. Wallahu A’lam Baarakallahu Feekum